Windows 10 Can’t Ping Another Computer on the Network: Getting Replies Between PCs at Home
You want to check whether two PCs on your network can see each other, so you open Command Prompt and type ping followed by the other computer’s name or address. The reply is “Request timed out” or “Destination host unreachable,” even though both PCs have internet access. When PAGODA 127 Windows 10 can’t ping another computer on the network, sharing files and printers between them usually fails too.
Ping sends a small test message called an ICMP echo request. Windows Defender Firewall blocks incoming ping requests by default on many PCs, especially when the network is set to Public. So a PC can be fully reachable for other services but still ignore ping.
Other causes include wrong IP addresses, devices on separate networks, or a router feature called client isolation that stops devices talking to each other.
Checking the firewall and the network setup usually explains the silence.
Why This Happens
Ping fails for these reasons:
- Windows Defender Firewall blocks incoming ICMP echo requests.
- The network profile is Public, which applies stricter rules.
- The PCs are on different subnets or one connects to a guest network.
- The router’s AP isolation or client isolation separates wireless devices.
Pinging by name can fail even when pinging by IP address works, because name resolution is a separate system.
Start With These Basic Checks
Confirm addresses and network type.
- On each PC, open Command Prompt and type ipconfig to note the IPv4 address.
- Check that both addresses start the same way, such as 192.168.1.x.
- Ping the other PC by its IP address rather than its name.
- Set both networks to Private in Settings > Network & Internet > Status > Properties.
- Make sure neither PC is connected to a guest Wi-Fi network.
Remember that the PC you ping must be awake. Many PCs sleep after a few minutes of inactivity, and a sleeping computer will not reply to ping or to file sharing requests.
Going a Step Further
Allow ping through the firewall.
- On the PC that does not reply, open Windows Defender Firewall with Advanced Security from Control Panel.
- Select Inbound Rules.
- Find “File and Printer Sharing (Echo Request – ICMPv4-In)” for the Private profile.
- Right-click it and choose Enable Rule.
- Ping that PC again.
If wireless devices cannot reach each other, open the router settings and turn off AP or client isolation for your main network.
A Word of Caution
Enable ping replies only on Private networks you trust. Keep third-party firewalls consistent with these changes, since they may block ping separately.
Final Thoughts
Failed pings usually come from the firewall blocking echo requests, a Public profile, or separate networks. Check IP addresses, set the network to Private, enable the ICMPv4 inbound rule, and disable router isolation if needed.